PS4 DualShock Wireless Controller

I bought 2 controllers. Both are red, which is fine, and both came uncleaned with grime in the seams and on the buttons. The bag for one of the controllers had been opened already and was missing the charging cable. I feel like the original listing was unclear they were refurbished, and if I had paid the original asking price of $60 each I would have returned them and asked for a refund. As is, I'm not very pleased and will have to strongly consider if it would be worth the gamble to order from them again.

Wrong color, unusable charging cable

The controller wasn't the same color as the one in the picture and the charger cord was unusable after the first day