Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

PEANUT BUTTER FUDGE - Amish Homemade Smooth & Creamy Recipe

(1)

Old World Amish

Blue Raspberry Twists

$2.37

Old World Amish

12 Flavor Gummi Bears

$5.39

The Marketplace at Cowtown

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeye

$0.99

Old World Amish

Assorted Fruit Twists

$4.77

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

APRICOT JAM - 100% All Natural Amish Homemade Spread

Old World Amish

Mini Peanut Butter Cups

$4.69

Old World Amish

Homestyle Chunky Potato Soup Mix

$4.49

Sweetz & More

Milk Chocolate Buckeyes 10 oz.

(4)

$7.99

Old World Amish

Amish Sugar Cookies

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

PEACH JAM - Amish Homemade Sweet Summer Fruit Spread

Old World Amish

Spearmint Starlites

$2.79

Old World Amish

Mini Dark Chocolate Raspberry Cups

(1)

$4.69

Old World Amish

Vanilla Milk Chocolate Caramels

$4.39

Old World Amish

Oatmeal Scotchies

(1)

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

OLD FASHIONED CHOCOLATE FUDGE

Old World Amish

Candy Corn

$4.57

Old World Amish

Green Bean Chips

$6.49

Spectrum Fudge

Milk Chocolate Mini Buckeyes

$7.00

Old World Amish

Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies

(1)

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

FAMILY GIFT BASKET - Best of Cheese, Sweets & Condiments with Wood Toy

$355.97

Old World Amish

Sanded Horehound Drops

$3.09

Fall baking staples

Flours, spices, apple butter, and streusel toppers.

23% off

Treats and Boards

Handcrafted Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeye - Half Pound

$11.50$14.99

Old World Amish

Brown Sugar Cookies

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

STRAWBERRY JAM - Amish Homemade Fresh Fruit Spread

Old World Amish

Assorted Jolly Rancher Candy

$6.65

Bedtime tea ritual

Chamomile, mint, rooibos, and honey add-ins.

Old World Amish

Mini Chocolate Coated Pretzels

$11.45

Old World Amish

Jelly Filled Turtles

$4.59

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

DARK CHOCOLATE FUDGE - Amish Handmade "Zarbitter" (Bittersweet)

Old World Amish

Watermelon Sour Patch

$5.59

Old World Amish

Cherry Twists

$2.39

Old World Amish

Homemade Buckeyes

$12.70

Old World Amish

Green Apple Twists

$2.09

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

FOUR BEAN SALAD - Delicious Mix in Sweet Brine Amish Homemade

Old World Amish

Cheddar Cheez Powder

$4.49

Old World Amish

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Calico Bean Market

Dark Chocolate Mini Buckeyes

$4.93

Old World Amish

Blue Raspberry Frooties

$4.37

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

APPLE BUTTER - Amish Fresh Homemade Spread with No Preservatives USA

$15.97

Old World Amish

Assorted Salt Water Taffy

$2.29

Old World Amish

Strawberry Wheels

$3.69

Old World Amish

Milk Chocolate Bridge Mix

$5.69

Old World Amish

Amish Wedding Cookies

(1)

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

SMOOTH & CREAMY VANILLA FUDGE - Amish Homemade

Old World Amish

Sour Watermelon Slices

$3.69

Cozy fall breakfast

Granola, oat cups, and nut butter.

Old World Amish

Milk Chocolate Almonds

$6.79

Old World Amish

Milk Chocolate Panned Peanuts

$5.44

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

TASTE OF PENNSYLVANIA GIFT BOX - 9 Gourmet Cheeses 5 Condiments & Crackers

$260.97

Old World Amish

Cheddar Ranch Dip Mix

$6.45

Old World Amish

Caramel Nut Cookies

(1)

Gretel's Candy

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes Bulk

$14.98

Old World Amish

Spearmint Leaves

$2.49

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

SWEET DILL PICKLES - 16 & 32 oz Jars Amish Homemade in Lancaster USA

(1)

Old World Amish

Chai Tea Mix

$6.15

Old World Amish

Strawberry Yogurt Pretzels

$5.99

Old World Amish

Mini Cow Tales

$3.79

Old World Amish

Gummi Worms

$3.49

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

BREAD & BUTTER PICKLE CHUNKS - 16 & 32 oz Jars Amish Homemade in Lancaster USA

Old World Amish

Assorted Fruit Slices

$5.57

Old World Amish

Red Raspberry Twists

$2.49

Old World Amish

Salted Caramels

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

BREAD & BUTTER PICKLES - 16 & 32 oz Jars Amish Homemade in Lancaster USA

Old World Amish

Dark Chocolate Cranberries

$6.29

Old World Amish

Cherry Slices

$3.75

Old World Amish

Snickerdoodle Cookies

All City Candy

Mini Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes - Bulk Bags

$17.25

Old World Amish

Black Raspberry Jam

$5.99

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

SWEET KOSHER PICKLES - 16 & 32 oz Jars Amish Homemade in Lancaster USA

Old World Amish

Yogurt Mini Pretzels

$4.59

Old World Amish

Orange Slices

$4.99

Old World Amish

Peanut M&Ms

$8.05

Old World Amish

Dark Chocolate Buckeyes

$6.29

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

COUNTRY BASKET - 11 Classic Tasty Treats in 1

$147.97

Old World Amish

Sanded Rootbeer Drops

$3.09

CandyFavorites

Mini Milk Chocolate and Peanut Butter Buckeyes

$24.59

Old World Amish

Chocolate Malt Balls

$6.49

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

YUMMY PICKLES - 16 & 32 oz Jars Amish Homemade in Lancaster USA