Suggested searches

Plant-based protein powders
Vegan leather handbags
Bedroom decor
Waterproof jackets
Hoodies

Learn more about how we use your data to personalize your experience and ads. Recommendations are for informational purposes only.

Cabot Creamery

The Cheese Pairing Collection by Cabot Creamery features award-winning cheeses, jam, caramel, and maple spiced pecans—all arranged for perfect gourmet pairings.

The Cheese Pairing Collection by Cabot Creamery features award-winning cheeses, jam, caramel, and maple spiced pecans—all arranged for perfect gourmet pairings.

Cabot Creamery

Cheese Pairing Collection

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$72.00

Color

Black

Quantity

Product description loading

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

You might also like

Blake Hill Preserves

Raspberry Hibiscus Preserve 10.8oz

(1)

A package of Cabot Creamery Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese features ten individually wrapped cheese snack sticks with bold cheddar flavor and a red and black plaid design.

Cabot Creamery

Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese

(7)

Blake Hill Preserves

Naked Raspberry Spread 10.4oz

(9)

Stacks of Cabot Creamery Sharp Cheddar Cheese Snacks, 50 ct, are arranged in three piles against a plain white background. The protein-packed cheese is wrapped in green and cream packaging with red accents.

Cabot Creamery

Sharp Cheddar Cheese Snacks, 50 ct

(8)

Cabot Creamery

Vermont Sharp Cheddar Cheese

(19)

Cabot Creamery Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese is an 8 oz (227g) block, aged 12 months for bold flavor. This lactose-free cheddar comes wrapped in clear plastic with a blue and white label.

Cabot Creamery

Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

(16)

Three Cabot Creamery Cracker Cut Collection packs, stacked diagonally, showcase cheddar cheese, smoky bacon, and pepper jack varieties. Each pack features appetizing images of cheese slices adorned with delicious toppings.

Cabot Creamery

Cracker Cut Collection

Tillamook Shop

Extra Sharp Cheddar Baby Loaf

(8)

Saratoga Olive Oil

Saratoga Olive Oil

4.9

(2.1K)

Tuscan Herb Olive Oil

Tuscan Herb Olive Oil

Garlic Olive Oil

Traditional 18-Year Balsamic Vinegar

Sicilian Lemon Balsamic Vinegar

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

& Maple - Turkey Brine

An 8 oz package of Cabot Creamery Wildly Horseradish Cheddar Cheese with a purple and cream label, highlighting its zesty horseradish cheddar flavor.

Cabot Creamery

Wildly Horseradish Cheddar Cheese

(9)

tillamook shop - farmers' collection english-style sweet cheddar cheese - 2022

Tillamook Shop

Farmers' Collection English-Style Sweet Cheddar

(12)

Tillamook Shop

Maker’s Reserve® Aged Sweet Cheddar

(3)

Blake Hill Preserves

Apricot with Orange & Honey 10.8oz

(3)

Blake Hill Preserves

Fruit Mince Pie Filling 16oz

(1)

Blake Hill Preserves

Classic Orange Marmalade 10.8oz

(1)

Experience the Cabot Creamery Cheese Block Party Pack, featuring twelve flavorful varieties of cheese blocks—including Mild, Monterey Jack, Vermont Sharp Cheddar, Colby Jack, Pepper Jack, Extra Sharp, Gouda, Horseradish, Seriously Sharp, Muenster, and Habanero—all neatly stacked in three rows.

Cabot Creamery

Cheese Block Party Pack

Tillamook Shop

Tillamook Shop

4.9

(359)

Cabot Creamery’s Gouda & Sharp Variety Pack Cheese Snacks includes gluten-free, lactose-free, high-protein Gouda and Vermont Sharp Cheddar in snack sizes.

Cabot Creamery

Gouda & Sharp Variety Pack Cheese Snacks

(1)

A package of Cabot Creamery Lite50 Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 8 oz, featuring a blue and white label that highlights this low fat cheddar as a healthy snack with 50% less fat and 33% fewer calories.

Cabot Creamery

Lite50 Sharp Cheddar Cheese

(10)

A 1 lb (453g) brick of Cabot Creamery Private Stock Cheddar Cheese, aged 16 months, Classic Vermont variety, with farm artwork on the packaging.

Cabot Creamery

Private Stock Cheddar Cheese

(12)

Blake Hill Preserves

Naked Strawberry Spread 10.4oz

(9)

Cabot Creamery

Farmhouse Reserve Cheddar Cheese

(9)

tillamook shop - farmers' collection extra sharp aged white cheddar cheese - 2022

Tillamook Shop

Farmers' Collection Extra Sharp Aged White Cheddar

(2)

Blake Hill Preserves

Pumpkin Maple Butter 11.4oz

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Vermont Farmstead Cheese Windsordale Variety Gift Pack

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

4.8

(1.4K)

Blake Hill Preserves

Gooseberry with Elderflower 10.8oz

(3)

Blake Hill Preserves

Strawberry Rhubarb Preserve 10.8oz

(2)

A stack of Cabot Creamery Gouda Cheese Snacks, 50 ct, is arranged in rows against a white background. The yellow and orange packaging stands out, with each snack clearly labeled "Gouda Cheese.

Cabot Creamery

Gouda Cheese Snacks, 50 ct

(4)

Cabot Creamery

Gouda Cheese

(5)

A 1 lb (453g) block of Cabot Creamery Vintage Choice Cheddar Cheese, aged 24 months, in black packaging with a cream and purple label, labeled Classic Vermont.

Cabot Creamery

Vintage Choice Cheddar Cheese

(3)

A 6-ounce block of Cabot Creamery White Oak Cheddar Cheese, a lactose free cheddar in a beige and black package, labeled “super premium aged cheddar cheese” with notes of caramel sweetness.

Cabot Creamery

White Oak Cheddar Cheese

(11)

Cabot Creamery

Horseradish Cheddar Cheese

(9)

Tillamook Shop

Farmers' Collection Extra Sharp Aged Cheddar

(2)

Blake Hill Preserves

Naked Classic Chocolate Spread 10.4oz

(2)

Chocolate cake with a slice on a plate, surrounded by chocolate chips and a fork on a marble surface.

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Cold Hollow | Chocolate Lovers

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Grafton - Maple Smoked Cheddar

(9)

Blake Hill Preserves

Date & Cumin Chutney 10.4oz

(1)

Blake Hill Preserves

Tart Cherry with Cardamom & Port 10.8oz

(4)

Fall baking staples

Fall baking staples

Flours, spices, apple butter, and streusel toppers.

Cabot Creamery Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese Snacks, 50 ct, are stacked in groups on a white background. Each individually wrapped bar features red, white, and yellow packaging with clear labels.

Cabot Creamery

Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese Snacks, 50 ct

(16)

Cabot Creamery Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese comes in a blue plaid bag with 10 snack sticks. The labels highlight protein content and note that it’s farmer-owned cheese.

Cabot Creamery

Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

(4)

Cabot Creamery Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese comes in an 8 oz deli bar with a red and white label, aged 18 months for a bold, nutty flavor.

Cabot Creamery

Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese

(21)

Tillamook Shop

Farmers' Collection Smoked Black Pepper White Cheddar

(16)

A beige and blue package of Cabot Creamery Lite50 Sharp Cheddar Cheese Snacks features 50% less fat, 33% fewer calories, and 6g protein per bar. Each healthy pack contains 36 individually wrapped bars.

Cabot Creamery

Lite50 Sharp Cheddar Cheese Snacks

(5)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Vermont Farmstead Alehouse Cheddar Cheese

(1)

Cabot Creamery Gouda Cheese comes in a clear container with 26 slices—an ideal protein snack for any occasion.

Cabot Creamery

Gouda Cheese

(4)

Blake Hill Preserves

Naked Chocolate Mint Spread 10.4oz

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Snack Attack Pack

Cabot Creamery Pepper Jack Cheese features zesty snack sticks made with spicy cheese. The red and green plaid 10-pack of 0.75 oz sticks is high in protein, farmer-owned, and lactose free.

Cabot Creamery

Pepper Jack Cheese

(10)

A 7 oz package of Cabot Creamery Pepper Jack Cheese cracker cut slices, with creamy spicy cheese slices visible through a clear plastic container and topped with a green and red label.

Cabot Creamery

Pepper Jack Cheese

(10)

Blake Hill Preserves

Heirloom Apple with Maple Syrup 10.8oz

(1)

A package of Cabot Creamery Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese with 26 aged cheddar slices, visible through a clear container topped by a red, black, and white label.

Cabot Creamery

Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese

(6)

A clear plastic container of Cabot Creamery Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese with 26 pre-sliced pieces. The package features a black, white, and gold label, displaying the cheddar slices inside.

Cabot Creamery

Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

(3)

A clear plastic pack of Cabot Creamery Vermont Sharp Cheddar Cheese contains 26 sliced cheddar cuts, labeled in green and cream.

Cabot Creamery

Vermont Sharp Cheddar Cheese

(2)

Back-to-school breakfast

Back-to-school breakfast

Pancake mixes, yogurt, and seed butters.

A block of Cabot Creamery 10 Year Cheddar Cheese in black packaging with a beige label, featuring Limited Reserve and rustic texture details, and Net Wt. 6.5oz (184g).

Cabot Creamery

10 Year Cheddar Cheese

(27)

An 8 oz (226g) round tub of Cabot Creamery Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese features a red lid and a cream, blue, and red label with clear branding and product details.

Cabot Creamery

Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

(8)

Cabot Creamery Pepper Jack Cheese is a lactose free 8 oz (226g) spicy cheese with mild and medium peppers, featuring green accents and a red pepper illustration on the label.

Cabot Creamery

Pepper Jack Cheese

(11)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery - Cilantro Onion Hot Sauce

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Sugar Bob's - Smoked Maple BBQ Sauce

A 10-count pack of Cabot Creamery Colby Jack Cheese features individually wrapped, creamy snack sticks in a blue and yellow plaid package with a clear window—ideal for everyday snacking.

Cabot Creamery

Colby Jack Cheese

(4)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Cold Hollow Jerky Gift Pack

A 6-ounce block of Cabot Creamery New York Vintage Cheddar Cheese, a lactose-free cheddar from the Legacy Collection, in beige and black packaging with red and gold accents and descriptive text.

Cabot Creamery

New York Vintage Cheddar Cheese

(3)

Cabot Creamery Pepper Jack Cheese, gluten-free and supremely creamy, comes in a red-and-beige plaid package with 9 convenient pre-sliced pieces—ideal for anyone who loves spicy cheese.

Cabot Creamery

Pepper Jack Cheese

A 7-ounce Cabot Creamery Pimento Cheese Spread features a red lid, Vermont cheddar on the label, orange accents, cheese imagery, and classic spread branding.

Cabot Creamery

Pimento Cheese Spread

(10)

An 8 oz package of Cabot Creamery Smoky Bacon Cheddar Cheese with a beige and pink label, made with real bacon and hickory smoke cheddar flavor.

Cabot Creamery

Smoky Bacon Cheddar Cheese

(10)

A round container of Cabot Creamery Port Wine Cheddar Cheese, 8 oz, with a red lid and cream and purple accents, features farmer-owned and co-op certifications—ideal for cocktail parties.

Cabot Creamery

Port Wine Cheddar Cheese

(13)

Blake Hill Preserves

Naked Peach Spread 10.4oz

(5)

Cabot Creamery

Colby Jack Cheese

A 6 oz block of Cabot Creamery Alpine Cheddar Cheese—lactose free, super premium aged cheddar with Swiss and Parmesan notes in cream and black packaging; ideal for a cheeseboard.

Cabot Creamery

Alpine Cheddar Cheese

(12)

Elevated sandwich essentials

Elevated sandwich essentials

Breads, pickles, and tinned fish.

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Cabot VT Specialty Popcorn Giftpack

(7)