Key Lime Pie

Name: Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups Key Lime Pie - Key Lime Pie
Brand: Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups
SKU: 42680661999804
Price: 36.5 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 5 (1 reviews)

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$36.50

Purchase at Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Color

Black

Quantity

Description

Mariposa's Key Lime Pie is a classic GF dessert with a smooth, tangy, and creamy filling made from lemon and lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, and sour cream, all set in a buttery graham cracker crust. It has a perfect balance of sweet...

Reviews

5.0

1 rating

Delicious Dessert

Tangy, tasty. Great textures. Delicious. Try it!

Anonymous · June 30, 2025

Delivery & Returns

Visit Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups for full shipping details

Shipping calculated at checkout

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

4.9 (95)

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Raspberry Squares - 4pk

(3)

$17.00

The Cake Bake Shop®

Key Lime Pie

(3)

$72.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Vanilla Strawberry Layer Cake

(8)

$54.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Hot Dog Buns - 6pk

$13.75

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

New & Improved Soft Pretzel

$5.75

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

California Lemon Cake

$14.75

I Love Pie Bakeshop

Key Lime Pie

$18.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Banana Muffin

$5.95

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Penguinos - 4pk

$14.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Ham + Cheese Pastry Pocket

$13.50

Taco Tuesday favorites

Tortillas, slaws, and salsas.

Piemazing

Key Lime Pie

$30.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Baguette

(1)

$6.95

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Pecan Pie

(6)

$24.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Spinach Ricotta Ravioli

(1)

$12.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Flourless Chocolate Torte

(2)

$40.00

Award-winning Key Lime Pie from Key West, Florida

Holy Crab Delivery

Traditional Key Lime Pie | Award-Winning

(4)

$29.99

Marinko’s

Strawberry Cream

$13.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

'Rye' Round

$10.95

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Berry Muffin

$5.95

Boichik Bagels

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Mocha Chocolate Layer Cake

(7)

$50.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Butter Croissant

$5.75

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Lemon Almond Tea Loaf

$16.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Sandwich Bread

(1)

$10.75

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Sandwich Rolls - 5pk

(2)

$13.50

Chef Lowell, LLC

Key Lime Pie

$45.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Cornbread Muffin - 4pk

$18.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Almond Biscotti

(1)

$13.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Mocha Cupcakes

$6.00

Mariposa Baking Co.

4.7

(1.5K)

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Raspberry Almond Ricotta Cake

(3)

$40.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Vanilla Mini Cupcakes - 12pk

$25.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Cinnamon Roll

$6.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Coconut Lemon Square

$4.95

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Chocolate Cupcakes

(3)

$6.00

Mundodeestilos

CONFITURAS BLA&WHITE DE FRESA Y CHOCOLATE

$0.39

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

4pk Pumpkin Muffins

(1)

$18.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Rustic Croutons

$8.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

GF Flour Blend

$7.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Bacon, Olive & Cheese Spiral

(1)

$11.50

Louie and Honey's Kitchen LLC

Key Lime Pie

(5)

$45.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Focaccia

$10.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Glazed Cinnamon Sugar Donuts

$4.75

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Molasses Cookies

$3.75

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Black & White 3-Layer Cake

(13)

$64.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Cheesecake

(4)

$36.00

Elevated sandwich essentials

Breads, pickles, and tinned fish.

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Spanakopita (Spinach + Feta) Pocket

$13.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Coconut Pecan Macaroons - 6pk

$13.50

Coastal Key Lime Pie

Mini Key Lime Pie (5") (LOCAL PICKUP ONLY)

(3)

$9.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Graham Crackers

$14.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

10in Pizza Crust - 2pk

$13.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Challah

(2)

$11.75

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Carrot Cupcakes

(1)

$6.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

6" Chicken Pot Pie

$15.75

A pie on a wooden table, one with a creamy top.

Pie Bar

Key Lime Pie

(7)

$36.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Dinner Rolls - 6pk

(1)

$14.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

"Shortbread" Cookies

$13.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Ginger Spice Biscotti

$13.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Apple Cinnamon Hand Pie

$7.50

Melao PR

Chocolate Berry Torte

(1)

$38.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Sour Cream Coffeecake

(1)

$14.75

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Buttermilk Biscuits - 4pk

$18.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Seasonal 'Butter' Cookies - 6pk

$15.25

Harlem Baking Company

Classic Key Lime Pie

(1)

$7.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Pistachio Nut Cake

(1)

$21.00

Hosting chips and dip night

Herby dips, scoop chips, and kettle classics.

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Viennese Tea Cookies - 10pk

$13.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Cheddar Almond Scone

$6.25

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Chocolate Chunk Cookies

$3.75

Coastal Key Lime Pie

Chocolate Dipped Key Lime Pie (LOCAL PICKUP ONLY)

(1)

$8.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Cherry Turnover

$7.25

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Cinnamon Raisin Bread

(1)

$12.75

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Polar Bears - 4pk

$14.50

Key Lime Pie Co

Key Lime Pie

(24)

$24.99

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Carrot Layer Cake

(4)

$56.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Tiramisu

(1)

$20.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Pain Au Chocolat

(1)

$6.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Chocolate Mini Cupcakes - 12pk

$25.00

Bean & Pie

GF Key Lime

$17.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

New York Crumb Cake

$22.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Chocolate Chip Cookies

$3.75

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

6"in Pizza Crust - 6pk

$17.50

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Vanilla Almond Pound Cake

(1)

$15.00

Pie Snob Bakery

Key Lime

(3)

$31.00

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Triple Chocolate Brownie

$4.95

Instant noodle upgrades

Noodles, chili crisp, and broth boosters.

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

Lemon Poppyseed Muffin

$5.95

Tootie Pie Co

Key Lime Pie

(1)

$30.00

Key Lime Pie

Reviews

Delivery & Returns

Mariposa Baking Co. | Pick-Ups

You might also like

Raspberry Squares - 4pk

Key Lime Pie

Vanilla Strawberry Layer Cake

Hot Dog Buns - 6pk

New & Improved Soft Pretzel

California Lemon Cake

Key Lime Pie

Banana Muffin

Penguinos - 4pk

Ham + Cheese Pastry Pocket

Key Lime Pie

Baguette

Pecan Pie

Spinach Ricotta Ravioli

Flourless Chocolate Torte

Traditional Key Lime Pie | Award-Winning

Strawberry Cream

'Rye' Round

Berry Muffin

Boichik Bagels

Mocha Chocolate Layer Cake

Butter Croissant

Lemon Almond Tea Loaf

Sandwich Bread

Sandwich Rolls - 5pk

Key Lime Pie

Cornbread Muffin - 4pk

Almond Biscotti

Mocha Cupcakes

Mariposa Baking Co.

Raspberry Almond Ricotta Cake

Vanilla Mini Cupcakes - 12pk

Cinnamon Roll

Coconut Lemon Square

Chocolate Cupcakes

CONFITURAS BLA&WHITE DE FRESA Y CHOCOLATE

4pk Pumpkin Muffins

Rustic Croutons

GF Flour Blend

Bacon, Olive & Cheese Spiral

Key Lime Pie

Focaccia

Glazed Cinnamon Sugar Donuts

Molasses Cookies

Black & White 3-Layer Cake

Cheesecake

Spanakopita (Spinach + Feta) Pocket

Coconut Pecan Macaroons - 6pk

Mini Key Lime Pie (5") (LOCAL PICKUP ONLY)

Graham Crackers

10in Pizza Crust - 2pk

Challah

Carrot Cupcakes

6" Chicken Pot Pie

Key Lime Pie

Dinner Rolls - 6pk

"Shortbread" Cookies

Ginger Spice Biscotti

Apple Cinnamon Hand Pie

Chocolate Berry Torte

Sour Cream Coffeecake

Buttermilk Biscuits - 4pk

Seasonal 'Butter' Cookies - 6pk

Classic Key Lime Pie

Pistachio Nut Cake

Viennese Tea Cookies - 10pk

Cheddar Almond Scone

Chocolate Chunk Cookies

Chocolate Dipped Key Lime Pie (LOCAL PICKUP ONLY)

Cherry Turnover

Cinnamon Raisin Bread

Polar Bears - 4pk

Key Lime Pie

Carrot Layer Cake

Tiramisu