Old Witch Button Pin

Cats Like Us

Vintage Gold Wicker Rocking Chair Pin

Fun Services Colorado

Vintage Halloween Flying Witch Button

$1.99

Fun Services Colorado

Vintage Halloween Classic Witch Button

$1.99

Bite Your Granny

Wicked Witch Inspired Button Pin Badge

$3.00

Holy Pins

Witch

$20.00

Cats Like Us

Silver Leaves Brooch

An enamel pin shaped like a Tamagotchi that reads "Pocket Familiar" at the top. It has a pink and purple shell. The screen has moon phases and a bat with night stars by it. The buttons of the tamagotchi are moon phases.

Kitty With A Cupcake

Pocket Familiar Bat Virtual Pet Enamel Pin

(1)

Gold metal bat-shaped brooch featuring a cat adorned with dimensional bat wings

Brooch Pins™

Bat-Winged Cat Metal Brooch

Bite Your Granny

Edna The Evil Witch Inspired Enamel Pin

WhiskersClub

Creepy Cute Cat Blob Enamel Pin • Multi-Eyed Monster Kitty • Horror Kawaii Pin • Spooky Black Cat Pin • Alt Goth Lapel Accessory

(1)

$14.99

Cats Like Us

Vintage Gold Japanese Leaf Brooch

Glorp Gum

Halloweirdos 4: lil’ Witchy

Cats Like Us

Vintage Gold Swirl Leaf Brooch

Cats Like Us

Weird Ohs Gross Out Pin

These Are Things

Black Cat Witch Pin

Cats Like Us

Gold Bow & Pearl Brooch

kate gabrielle

Kitschy and Witchy enamel lapel pin

Xhilyn

Black Cat Witch Pin

Chic Halloween Pretty Witch With Hat Brooch - Fun Acrylic Fashion Pin

Exclusive offer available

Jaded Enterprises

Chic Halloween Pretty Witch With Hat Brooch - Fun Acrylic Fashion Pin

(1)

$9.95

Mindful Hookup LLC dba StarSeed Homestead

COZY WITCH HOUSE COTTAGE ENAMEL PIN

$15.00

Cats Like Us

Large Silver Feather Brooch

Dapple & Dot

WITCH CAT OF POTIONS PIN/MAGNET

(2)

Dapple & Dot

WITCH CAT OF VAMPIRES PIN/MAGNET

Playing Possum Clothing Co.

Pixel Ghost Button Pin

$1.50

A circular enamel pin with copper metal details. It has a maroon border with a light blue background and turquoise words that say "Book Witch". Also depicted are an open book with a bookmark, a red pair of glasses and a teacup. There are sparkles above the book.

Kitty With A Cupcake

Book Witch Enamel Pin

(1)

Lady Moon Co.®

Toad Witch Pin

(1)

An enamel pin shaped like a Tamagotchi that reads "Pocket Familiar" at the top. It has a mint green and peach shell. The screen has moon phases and a frog on a lily pad looking at a fly. The buttons of the tamagotchi are moon phases.

Kitty With A Cupcake

Pocket Familiar Frog Virtual Pet Enamel Pin

Cats Like Us

Gold Leaf Brooch

$24.00

Cats Like Us

Whoot Me Owl Brooch Pin

Dapple & Dot

ORANGE WITCH CAT PIN / MAGNET

Cats Like Us

Vintage Gold Poodle Dog Brooch

Bright Bat Design

Vintage Halloween Black Cat Enamel Pin

(2)

A circular hard enamel pin with rose gold metal. There is a mint green border around a pastel pink circle in the background. The bottom of the pin has bubble letters in purple that read "Basic Witch" above this there is a black cauldron with yellow moon phases full of bubbles. There is a broom above this and a black pointed hat to the right of the broom. Sparkles are around all of the objects.

Kitty With A Cupcake

Basic Witch Enamel Pin

(1)

Strange Ways

Reading Witch Pin

(1)

$8.99

Cats Like Us

Large Cascading Rhinestone Brooch

$28.00

Enamel pin depicting a cat in a ghost outfit crouching.

LOADUP.CO

Crouching Ghost Cat Pin

(3)

$15.00

A circular enamel pin with a blue border, navy background, and maroon words that say "Lazy Witch". It has a vintage TV, bag of chips, a yellow couch and a black cat on the couch.

Kitty With A Cupcake

Lazy Witch Enamel Pin

(1)

Brian Kesinger Shop

Witch Cat Enamel Pin

15% off

Hopeless Romantic

Patience and Poe Halloween Pin

$34.00$40.00

Cats Like Us

Kirk's Folly Large Fairy Dangling Brooch Pin

$88.00

Bite Your Granny

I'll Get You My Pretty Wicked Witch Inspired Button Pin Badge

$3.00

Fluff Bread

Peek-a-Mew Black Cat Halloween Pin

$13.99

Bite Your Granny

Grotbags Button Pin Badge

(2)

$3.00

Strange Ways

Black Cat Witch Pin

(1)

$8.99

Faerie Magazine

Halloween Witch Hat enamel pin

$14.00

Cats Like Us

Gold Round Leaves Brooch

Fun Services Colorado

Vintage Halloween Scratch Cat Button

$1.99

An enamel pin in the shape of a tamagotchi virtual pet. It has a black cat on the screen and reads "Pocket Familiar" across the top. It is a pink shell with yellow details.

Kitty With A Cupcake

Pocket Familiar Cat Virtual Pet Enamel Pin

(1)

An enamel pin in the shape of a Furby with a tattoo style banner around its body that says "Always Watching". The Furby is light blue with peach and lavender spots.

Kitty With A Cupcake

Always Watching Enamel Pin

(1)

Cats Like Us

Jelly Belly Tropical Bird Pin

Strange Ways

Witch Baby Pin

$8.99

Rather Keen

Pinup Witch pin - Glow-in-the-dark wicked witch brooch

$13.00

Cat Coven

Pumpkittens - Enamel Pin

(1)

Crafty Celts

Cat Pin

$45.00

Cats Like Us

Thin Silver Leaf Brooch

Magical by Marissa

OLD FASHIONED PIN

(3)

$13.99

kate gabrielle

Witch undertones enamel lapel pin

Pin & Tonic

Witch's Cat Enamel Pin

Cats Like Us

Pink Rhinestone Pig Brooch Pin

$18.00

Exclusive offer available

Jaded Enterprises

Vintage Style Witch Hat Brooch – Rhinestone Accents – Halloween Jewelry Pin

$11.95

A tudor house shaped pin. The house is purple, it has a pentacle window, and a flower box. There is a raven perched on the roof and a cat sleeping in front of the house. There is a broom, pumpkin and cauldron outside.

Kitty With A Cupcake

Cozy Witch House Enamel Pin

(2)

$15.00

Medusa's Makeup

Skeleton Kitty Pin

A circular enamel pin. It has a brown border with a sage green background and letters in light blue that read "Cottage Witch". It has a floral teapot, strawberry jam jar, and red mushrooms depicted on it.

Kitty With A Cupcake

Cottage Witch Enamel Pin

(1)

Cats Like Us

The Nostalgia Express Train Pin

$30.00

33% off

Kitty With A Cupcake

💜B-GRADE💜 Cozy Witch House Enamel Pin

$10.00$15.00

Our Super Adventure Official Online Store

Cauldron Cat Pin Badge

TRUECOLOR WHOLESALE

Spooky Halloween Witch Hat Brooch Pin – Rhinestone Trimmed Enamel Badge with Jack-o'-Lantern Charm (CC1249)

Of Aspen Curated Gifts

Haunted House Pin

$14.00

Cats Like Us

Kenneth Jay Lane Dangling Crystals Tree Brooch Pin

$58.00

Dapple & Dot

WITCH CAT OF FLOWERS PIN/MAGNET

Cowpoke Pins

INHAND - Witch Jinx

$62.50

Bright Bat Design

Vintage Halloween Witch Enamel Pin

(3)

Cats Like Us

Wishbone & Horseshoe Vintage Pins

Dapple & Dot

GREY WITCH CAT PIN / MAGNET

Black and white cat-shaped lapel pin on a pastel pink background

Brooch Pins™

Felix the Cat Lapel Pin

$7.00

Yesterdays

Witch Toad

Dapple & Dot

BLACK WITCH CAT PIN / MAGNET

Cats Like Us

NOS Poodle Dog Pin

Strange Ways

Lucky Cat Pin

$10.99

33% off

Kitty With A Cupcake

💜B-GRADE💜 Cottage Witch Enamel Pin

$8.00$12.00

An enamel pin set that is Polly Pocket style compact of a witch house with a little witch mini doll. The compact house has a cauldron, crystal ball, tarot cards, crystals, and a broom. The compact is a pastel peach color with mint green, hot pink and purple details.

Kitty With A Cupcake

Witchy Pocket Enamel Pin Set

(3)

Xhilyn

Bubblegum Kitty Witch Pin

Cats Like Us

Double Silver Etched Leaf Brooch

Bright Bat Design

Vintage Halloween Ghost Enamel Pin

(2)