Mud Pie | Toothpick Caddy Set, Assorted Styles

Monarch Boutique

Wine & Cheese Toothpick Caddy Sets

$9.95

Piper Lillies Gift Shoppe

Mud Pie 26 40430041x Tennis Toothpick Caddy Set - 3 Styles

Cute toothpick decoration for Thanksgiving

Annies Hallmark & Gretchens Hallmark

Mud Pie : Thanksgiving Toothpick Caddy Sets

$11.99

34% off

Smyth Jewelers

Mud Pie Easter Toothpick Caddy Sets 2026

$7.97$12.00

Shelby's

Mud Pie | Toile Dessert Plate, Assorted Designs

$18.50

Exclusive offer available

Craft Closet

Mudpie- Tailgate Toothpick Caddy Sets #40430047

$6.50

Steve's Hallmark

Farm Animal Toothpick Caddy Sets

$9.99

High Cotton Downtown

Golf Toothpicks

CeCe's Home & Gifts

Mud Pie Circa Holiday Toothpick Holder Set

$13.00

Shelby's

Mud Pie| Burl Wood Lidded Canisters

$71.00

Hot Pink Brentwood

Pink Base Flower Toothpick Holder

$12.50

Randy's Shoes

MUDPIE FLOWER EASTER TOOTHPICK HOLDER | PINK

$12.95

Pine & Moss

Fall Toothpick Holders- Three Styles

$9.00

shopflowersplus.com

MUD PIE TOPIARY TOOTHPICK CADDY SETS

Shelby's

Football Toothpick Server

$30.00

The Wreath Stand

Flower Toothpick Caddy Set

(1)

Exclusive offer available

Vine + Branch Florist

Easter Toothpick Caddy Set

$18.95

50% off

HighlandSide Interiors, Gifts and Monogramming

Easter Toothpick Holder with Toothpicks

$7.48$14.95

Eloise Trading Company

Wine & Cheese Toothpick Caddy

$11.00

The Gingham Pig… a Meat Boutique!

Farm Toothpick Caddy

Bar cart basics

Carts, glassware, and bottle storage.

Briarwood Gifts

Fall Toothpick Holders

$7.00

Exclusive offer available

Veranda Cafe & Mercantile

Fiesta Toothpick Caddy Set

$11.50

Hot Pink Brentwood

Pink Flower Toothpick Holder

$12.50

Shelby's

Mud Pie | Bunny Chip and Dip

$56.50

Adelyne's Boutique & Gifts

Thanksgiving Toothpick Caddy

$12.00

High Cotton Downtown

FARM ANIMAL TOOTHPICK CADDY SETS

$16.00

HighlandSide Interiors, Gifts and Monogramming

Wine and Cheese toothpick holders

$14.95

oshang

Shelby's

Mud Pie | Ceramic Bamboo Platter

$52.00

A. Dodson's

Wine & Cheese Toothpick Caddy Sets

$9.99

Aimaleigh's Boutique

Mudpie Toothpick Holder

$8.00

ImaginArte

Wine & Cheese Toothpick Caddy Sets

(1)

$13.50

Daisy and Dukes Boutique

Mud Pie Thanksgiving Toothpick Caddy Sets

$11.99

Aimaleigh's Boutique

Gather Toothpicks

$12.00

50% off

Hartz Honey Hole

Fall Toothpick Holder

(1)

$5.50$11.00

Monarch Boutique

Blue Willow Toothpicks & Holder

A. Dodson's

Scattered Rackets Toothpick

A. Dodson's

Crab Toothpick Holder

Shelby's

Mud Pie | Twisted Handle Mug

$18.50

CeCe's Home & Gifts

Mud Pie Farm Christmas Toothpick Holders - 4 Styles

(1)

$13.00

Heartisans Marketplace

Toothpick Holder

$9.95

A Sign of Grace, LLC DBA: Mezoozah Boutique & Corner Sweets

Thanksgiving Toothpick Set

$10.95

Piper Lillies Gift Shoppe

Mud Pie 26 40430037x Flower Toothpick Caddy Set - 4 Styles

Lit Decor and Gift

Easter Toothpick Caddy Set

The Ivy Cottage

Wine & Cheese Toothpick Caddy Sets

$10.95

The curated dining table

Dinnerware, glasses, and flatware.

The Merry Magnolia

Thanksgiving Toothpick Caddy Set

$12.50

CeCe's Home & Gifts

Mud Pie Christmas Toothpick Tray & Caddy Set - 2 Styles

(3)

$23.00

RSVP Gifts and More

Ceramic Toothpick Holder

(1)

$7.50

Lucy Rose

Topiary Toothpick Holder

$16.00

Piper Lillies Gift Shoppe

Mud Pie MP 40430010xx Gather Toothpick Sets

$11.50

Lit Decor and Gift

Stoneware Flower Toothpick Set

$13.99

NRS

Mud Pie Pick Ups Toothpick Holder

$7.00

Shelby's

Mud Pie | Bunny Pitcher

$46.00

The Wreath Stand

Topiary Toothpick Holder

A. Dodson's

Tennis Balls Toothpick

Briarwood Gifts

Gather Toothpick Set

$10.75

The Islander FMB

Mud Pie Shell Toothpick Caddy Set

$14.95

Tin Roof Gift Shop

Topiary Toothpick Holder

Piper Lillies Gift Shoppe

Mud Pie 26 40430039x Outdoor Retreat Toothpick Caddy Set - 4 Styles

(1)

shopflowersplus.com

MUD PIE THANKSGIVING TOOTHPICK CADDY

$10.99

CeCe's Home & Gifts

Mud Pie Golf Toothpick Holder Set - 3 Styles

$14.00

Shelby's

Chip & Dip Bowl Set

$72.00

A. Dodson's

Shell Toothpick Holder

Piper Lillies Gift Shoppe

Mud Pie MP 40430007xx Fall Toothpick Holder Sets

$7.99

The Merry Magnolia

Wine & Cheese Toothpick Caddy

$10.00

Four blue and white ceramic topiary toothpick holders with decorative floral and pearl picks on a white background.

Exclusive offer available

Miss Daisy's Home

Topiary Toothpick Holder

A. Dodson's

Golf Cart Toothpick

Sculptural lamps under $150

Mushroom lamps, orb bases, and pleated cones.

Smyth Jewelers

Mud Pie Tidbit & Toothpick Sets

$11.00

The Bugs Ear

Wine and Cheese Toothpick Holder Mud Pie

$8.50

Tonya's Treasures Inc.

Sea Shell Toothpick Tray Set

$34.95

Piper Lillies Gift Shoppe

Mud Pie 26 40430042x Golf Toothpick Caddy Set - 3 Styles

Exclusive offer available

Emma Lou's Boutique

MudPie Easter Toothpick Caddy Sets

$13.90

Citrus and Moss

Easter Toothpick Caddy Sets, 4 assorted (sold separately)

$10.95

Tonya's Treasures Inc.

Gather Toothpick Set

$9.95

The Rustic Market

Tailgate Toothpick Caddy Sets

$14.00

Shelby's

Mud Pie | Pumpkin Knit Trivet, Assorted Colors

$10.00

40% off

Smyth Jewelers

Mud Pie Fall Toothpick Holder Set

(1)

$5.97$9.95

Exclusive offer available

Pretty N Bliss

Mud Pie Flower Toothpick Vase

$12.95

High Cotton Downtown

Woven Salt, Pepper & Toothpick Caddy Set

$19.99

Stitching Around Collections

Toothpick Holder

$8.00

Shelby's

Mud Pie| Turkey Salad Plate

$20.00

Findlay Rowe Designs

Mud Pie - Toothpick Holder - Golf