This is the product description text that will appear here.
Quantity
1
Description
Sometimes you can’t beat a classic New York plain bagel. This is Bagelista in its purest form! 24 hour slow-rise fermentation. Crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and the smell is unbelievable! Each package contains 4 large bagels.
Reviews
4.6
47 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
BEST BAGELS EVER!!!
We bought these bagels in the frozen section at Whole Foods. We were amazed at how crispy on the outside and doughy on the inside they were when cooking them in the air fryer. We loved them so much we went back for more. Unfortunately they didn’t sell them any more. We googled where to get them and no one had them. 😞 Hence, we ordered 4 bags online. They came quickly, freshly prebaked. We threw them in the freezer and have been enjoying them ever since. The only caveat was one of the bags was cut the wrong way. No big deal. Won’t stop us from ordering them again. Highly recommend these bagels! 10 star in our book
R
Rita · May 19, 2026
Authentic New Jersey/New York bagels
Bagelista has nailed it. It’s by far the best bagel you can toast up at home. I wake up every morning excited to start my breakfast routine. I like to wet the frozen bagel and sprinkle some sea salt on it so it sticks when I toast it
