Amish Paste Tomato

Name: Thresh Seed Co. Amish Paste Tomato - Amish Paste Tomato
Brand: Thresh Seed Co.
SKU: 44070229410041
Price: 3.99 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4.8947 (13 reviews)

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$3.99

Quantity

Color

Black

Quantity

Description

The Amish Paste Tomato is an heirloom variety that was discovered in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, but is thought to have originated in Wisconsin around 1870. Amish Paste's indeterminate plants produce good yields of 8- to 12-ounce, oblong or s...

Reviews

4.9

19 ratings

I wish they stayed alive….

Maybe it was me but I had planted these seeds in May and had a few plants growing, and then most of them died…..I have one left that’s small and hasn’t flowered like the rest of my tomato plants. I’m wondering if it was something I had done. We’ll see how it goes.

Layla · August 15, 2026

Amish paste tomatoes

We just transplanted the tomatoes and they are growing strong! We want to can some ths fall. Hoping for a big harvest. Thank you

Doris · August 8, 2026

I can’t wait to start these next season!

Melissa · August 18, 2026

Delivery & Returns

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

4.7 (1.5K)

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Black Beauty Zucchini

(7)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Cherokee Purple Tomato

(5)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Marconi Red Pepper

(14)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Cilantro

(5)

$3.99

Early Prolific Straightneck Summer Squash

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Early Prolific Straightneck Squash

(3)

$3.99

HOSS

4.7

(12.1K)

Open Seeds of the Month subscription box featuring four fall seed varieties—carrots, radishes, spinach, and lettuce—alongside a Hoss Gardening Club fall gardening guide.

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Beefsteak Tomato

(2)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Jalapeno Mild Chile Pepper

(2)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Purple Beauty Pepper

(3)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Red Wethersfield Onion

(1)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Rich Sweetness 132 Melon

(24)

$3.99

The Living Seed Company

Organic Amish Paste Tomato Seeds - Lycopersicon lycopersicum

(4)

$4.50

Gurneys

4.5

(4.3K)

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Heirloom Cutting Lettuce Mix

(3)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Garlic Chives

(2)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Ozark Giant Bell Pepper

(5)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Tommy Toe Tomato (Steakhouse)

(4)

$3.99

MIgardener

4.8

(34.1K)

Straight Eight Heirloom Slicing Cucumber

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Straight 8 Cucumber

(3)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Buttercrunch Lettuce

(3)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Azoychka Tomato

(1)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Andrew Rahart's Jumbo Red Tomato

(6)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Detroit Dark Red Beet

(3)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Long Island Improved Brussels Sprouts

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Italian Flat Leaf Parsley

(1)

$3.99

Bootstrap Farmer

4.9

(3.3K)

Black 1020 Microgreen shallow with holes

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Riesentraube Tomato

(1)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Reisetomate Traveler Tomato

(5)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Onion Chives

(2)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Black Cherry Tomato

(1)

$3.99

Southern Seeds

4.7

(5.7K)

Blueberry Cheesecake Zinnia – 100 Seeds seed packet from Seed Therapy – American-grown, heirloom seeds

Raspberry Sorbet Zinnia - 100 Seeds seed packet from Seed Therapy – American - grown, heirloom seeds

Lavender Zinnia – 100 Seeds seed packet from Seed Therapy – American - grown, heirloom seeds

Blushing Bride Zinnia Mix - 100 Seeds seed packet from Seed Therapy – American - grown, heirloom seeds

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Rutgers Tomato

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Anna Russian Tomato

(10)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

All Seasons Cabbage

(2)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Honeynut Squash

(5)

$3.99

Ferme Coop du Moulin

Tomate Amish Paste

CA$4.00

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Aji Amarillo Chile Pepper

(12)

$3.99

Renee's Garden

4.7

(1.2K)

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Orange Mini Bell Pepper

(3)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Di Cicco Broccoli

(1)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Minnesota Midget Melon

(8)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Yellow Monster Pepper

(1)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Small Sugar Pie Pumpkin

(1)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Bouquet Dill

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Clemson Spineless Okra

(2)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Craig's Grande Jalapeno

(4)

$3.99

Living room glow up

Chic lighting, side tables, and linen layers.

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Mortgage Lifter Tomato

(4)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Boston Pickling Cucumber

(3)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Blue Lake Pole Bean

(11)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Martino's Roma Tomato

(4)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Nadapeno Jalapeno Pepper

(8)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Danvers Carrot

(2)

$3.99

Alliance of Native Seedkeepers

4.7

(2.4K)

Pepper Seeds - Sweet - Keystone Giant - Alliance of Native Seedkeepers - Vegetable Seeds

Gray Bean Seeds - Pole - Cherokee Trail of Tears Beans Alliance Of Native Seedkeepers Vegetable Seeds

Sunflower Seeds - Velvet Queen - Alliance of Native Seedkeepers - Flower Seeds

Cucumber Seeds - Vining - Muncher Burpless - Alliance of Native Seedkeepers - Vegetable Seeds

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Lavender Hyssop

(3)

$3.99

Grand Seeds

Tomato Amish Paste Seeds – Heirloom Giant Sauce Favorite

(1)

$2.40

Black Krim Heirloom Purple Slicing Tomato

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Black Krim Tomato

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Tendersweet Carrot

(2)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Principe Borghese Tomato

(2)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Mammoth Long Island Dill

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Genovese Basil

(6)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Chocolate Cherry Tomato

(1)

$3.99

Noire de Coseboeuf Scalloped Purple Tomato

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Noire de Coseboeuf Tomato

(6)

$3.99

English cottage touches

Collected classics with country-house charm

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

German Pink Tomato

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Thessaloniki Tomato

(5)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Thyme, Winter (Common Thyme)

(2)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

National Pickling Cucumber

(1)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Wild Bergamot (Bee Balm)

(6)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Golden Detroit Beet

(5)

$3.99

RESTORATION SEEDS

Amish Gold

$3.50

GreenStalk Garden

4.9

(21.7K)

Butterfly Pins - Set of 28 | Multi-Color Pack

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Rosemary

(2)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Blondkopfchen Tomato

(3)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Purple Coneflower

(2)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Nantes Carrot

(5)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Super Sioux Tomato

(3)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Texas Tiny Cherry Tomato

(19)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

French Marigold

(8)

$3.99

Hensley Settlement Heirloom Yellow Tomato

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Hensley Settlement Tomato

(1)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Sweetie Tomato

(3)

$3.99

Bar cart basics

Carts, glassware, and bottle storage.

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Carliston Banana Pepper

(6)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Homemade Pickles Cucumber

(1)

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Thresh Seed Co.

Sugar Baby Watermelon

(7)

$3.99

The Farm at Worman Mill