Superstition Never Tasted This Good.
A rich, chewy black cocoa cookie packed with peanut butter chips and rolled in sugar — the cookie that started it all.
4.9
22 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Perfect combo, crisp outside and moist chewy inside.
A. · September 24, 2025
Absolute favs! And not because I'm a hometown fan.
E
Eleanor · December 27, 2022
Wonderful combo of rich, but not too sweet, chocolate and peanut butter. Fans of Reese's cup should find them addictive