Amish Sugar Cookies

Old World Amish

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Old World Amish

Pumpkin Cookies

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

PEANUT BUTTER FUDGE - Amish Homemade Smooth & Creamy Recipe

(1)

Old World Amish

Seedless Red Raspberry Jam

Old World Amish

Dill Pickle Spears

(1)

$4.69

Exclusive offer available

The Homemade Harvest

Sugar Cookie

(2)

$3.00

Old World Amish

Buttery Flavored Canola Oil

$4.75

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

OLD FASHIONED CHOCOLATE FUDGE

Old World Amish

Traffic Jam

Old World Amish

Chicken Base with Parsley

$6.65

Village Bakery

Sugar

$1.60

Old World Amish

Seven Bean Soup Mix

$3.49

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

REBECCA'S STRAWBERRY CRANBERRY PRESERVE - All Natural Amish Homemade Conserve

Old World Amish

Creamy Broccoli Soup Mix

$4.29

Old World Amish

Snickerdoodle Cookies

Old World Amish

Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies

(1)

Old World Amish

Exotic Rice Blend

$4.99

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

FOUR BEAN SALAD - Delicious Mix in Sweet Brine Amish Homemade

Old World Amish

Country Corn Chowder Soup Mix

$6.59

Old World Amish

Farm Dust Seasoning from Weavers Seasonings

$5.15

Old World Amish

Nonpareils

Old World Amish

Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes

$4.89

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

SWEET KOSHER PICKLES - 16 & 32 oz Jars Amish Homemade in Lancaster USA

Old World Amish

Spun Honey

$8.50

Fall baking staples

Flours, spices, apple butter, and streusel toppers.

Crows Nest Cookies

Sugar Cookie

(2)

$2.00

Old World Amish

Cinnamon Vanilla Nut Cappuccino Mix

$5.45

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

HOT PEPPER RELISH - Sweet & Hot Pepper Blend Amish Homemade Dip USA

Old World Amish

Saffron Jasmine Rice

$3.79

Bedtime tea ritual

Chamomile, mint, rooibos, and honey add-ins.

Old World Amish

Ginger Snaps

$6.40

Old World Amish

Happy Salt Blend

(1)

$7.75

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

HONEY SWEET APPLE BUTTER - Amish Fresh Homemade Spread with No Sugar Added

$18.97

Old World Amish

Black Turtle Beans

$2.95

Old World Amish

Brown and Wild Rice Blend

$5.07

Earth and Sugar

Cookies

$48.00

Old World Amish

Cheesy Bacon Potato Soup Mix

$5.95

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

ELDERBERRY JELLY - Amish Homemade Healthy Berry Spread USA

Old World Amish

Red Sweet Pepper Relish

$8.90

Old World Amish

Baby Lima Beans

$7.55

The Kosher Marketplace

Sugar Cookies

$11.99

Old World Amish

Seedless Black Raspberry Jam

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

APPLE BUTTER - Amish Fresh Homemade Spread with No Preservatives USA

$15.97

Old World Amish

Yellow Split Peas

$1.99

Old World Amish

Oatmeal Scotchies

(1)

Appalachia Cookie Company

Sugar

(4)

$62.00

Old World Amish

Old Fashioned Apple Sauce

$7.99

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

YUMMY PICKLES - 16 & 32 oz Jars Amish Homemade in Lancaster USA

Old World Amish

White Sanding Sugar

$5.60

Cozy fall breakfast

Granola, oat cups, and nut butter.

Gertel's Bakery

Sugar Cookies

$6.49

Old World Amish

Cheddar Broccoli Soup Mix

$5.85

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

BREAD & BUTTER PICKLES - 16 & 32 oz Jars Amish Homemade in Lancaster USA

Old World Amish

3/4 Inch Wide Country Style Noodles

$4.79

Old World Amish

Creamy Mushroom Soup Mix

$5.79

The Yummy Cookie

Sugar

$5.00

Old World Amish

Old Fashioned Hot Salsa

$3.99

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

SOUR CHERRY JAM - Amish Homemade Sweet & Tart Fruit Spread

Old World Amish

Butter Microwave Popcorn

$12.57

Old World Amish

Caramel Nut Cookies

(1)

Cookies, Then Milk

Sugar Cookie

(1)

$14.99

Old World Amish

Beef Bouillon Cubes

$11.45

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

DARK CHOCOLATE FUDGE - Amish Handmade "Zarbitter" (Bittersweet)

Old World Amish

Complete Chili Soup Mix

$8.47

Old World Amish

Old Fashioned Sauerkraut

$8.84

Terra Americana

Old World Cookies - Peanut Butter

$10.00

Old World Amish

Garden Vegetable Soup Mix

$4.69

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

STRAWBERRY JAM - Amish Homemade Fresh Fruit Spread

Old World Amish

Crispy Toasted Onion Bits

$7.22

Old World Amish

Creamy Caramel Cappuccino Mix

$3.99

Raineys Sweet Treats

Sugar

$15.00

Old World Amish

Chicken Dust Seasoning from Weavers Seasonings

$6.17

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

DILL BABY CORN - Nutricious Sweetcorn with NO SUGAR added

Old World Amish

Cheddar Lover's Snack Mix

$4.39

Old World Amish

Amish Wedding Cookies

(1)

Generations Kitchen TX

Sugar Cookies

(1)

$10.00

Old World Amish

Black Raspberry Jam

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

SWEET DILL PICKLES - 16 & 32 oz Jars Amish Homemade in Lancaster USA

Old World Amish

Thermaflo

$6.99

Old World Amish

Animal Crackers

$3.99

Old World Amish

Old Fashioned Vanilla Peaches

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

CLASSIC DILL PICKLES - 16 & 32 oz Jars NO SUGAR Amish Homemade in Lancaster USA

Old World Amish

Extra Large Caramel Popcorn

$3.50

Old World Amish

Homemade Amish Noodles 2lb Medium

$10.25

Old World Amish

Peanut Butter Monkey Munch

$10.74

Old World Amish

Lentil Beans

$2.39

Exclusive offer available

Saving Shepherd

BREAD & BUTTER PICKLE CHUNKS - 16 & 32 oz Jars Amish Homemade in Lancaster USA

Old World Amish

GF Pretzel Sticks 8oz