I got the discovery deodorant a while back & these were my two favorite. The black rose & out deodorant smelled so good & had nice tone of rose. The body spray in Black rose smells clean, but is very strong, smells like a guys cologne, no HINT of rose! The other is barely lighter, but nothing like what the deodorant smells like. While I am very sensitive to heavy smells, I don't even think I can wear either of these. I'm so sad! I decided to splurg & now I have two fairly expensive sive scents I can't even wear. Will not buy from here again.