It’s a very basic black lip liner. There’s no fragrance which is nice, but it also doesn’t smell like nothing. It’s very very waxy smelling but it goes on smooth over powdered cream foundation so I can ignore the smell. Are there better black lip liners available? Yes, but for the price point there really isn’t anything that could compare.

The color is not as pictured and it smells like dish soap, really disappointing!!

This is the perfect lip liner for me. I don’t like to wear lipstick so the creamy consistency feels nice. The color also matches my natural color so I just lip gloss on and it looks beautifully natural/ minimal. I’m ordering this in 3 more colors. I use this almost everyday and there is a lot of product in it.