i really like this honestly!! the color is beautiful and it feels nice on my lips. it’s just cute thing to use, i love the packaging!! i did have an issue at first where the first few swatches were clear likeeee tint at all.. i was confused and going to message customer service BUT i know makeup and sometimes formulas can mess up or be inconsistent. i figured it was just an issue of some the pigment settling differently than others + it is winter right now so that could also have to do with it!! i warmed with my palm and massaged the packaging a little bit and i swatch again and kept pressing it out until i saw the true espresso color! it really didn’t take much and was not much of a bother. i am so excited to use this with makeup looks soon🤎 i do recommend !!