I ordered my first one a couple weeks ago. When it came in, it exceeded my expectations! I've tried so many drug store and high end brands of liquid eye liner and have never been as satisfied as I have with this one. Easy to use and lasts A LONG TIME. I have oily lids so it's never been easy finding a good lasting liquid eye liner. But this one?? Hunny...I went to sleep with it and when I woke up, it still looked fresh. I have to use Vaseline to get out all off. I was sold after that. Had to hurry up and purchase another cause I know when the first one runs out, I'm not gonna wanna wait for my next order to come in.