mascara
it was clumpy, and i tested it by going out, i cried and it was very windy outside, that makes my eyes water even more, it did flake a bit.. but it did not stick to my face, i could wipe it away like nothing (i like that, doesnt leave a mark on my face). when i took it off it was flaking and got so much flakes in my eye, that hurt as i had to pick it out. very nice packaging and design. i like the wand and brush. it separates eyelashes very nice, im going to give it another try, for now this is my review <3