I finally found it!

Finally, finally, finally! I found a beautiful eyeliner with gray colors that I can easily apply and that stays on all day and looks great all day. I have been looking for years! I am so thrilled and also the mascara, what a great mascara. I will never buy another brand again.

I was very impressed that

I was very impressed that Thrive sent me a new container of eyeliner. The first one I had issues with twisting it to expand the pencil. I mentioned it in a comment, but never asked or expected a replacement. Great customer service and appreciated your response.

Highly recommend the eyeliner pencil!

I've bought several eyeliner pencils, but they pulled and drug on my eyelids. The Infinity eyeliner pencil goes on smooth and lasts for hours. I threw away all my other eyeliner pencils!