Great at first

I loved this eye liner at first. It went on so smoothly and stayed put. Then the tip needed to be sharpened. No matter how much product i shaved off the end of this eyeliner, i never could get the sharp line i experienced at first. I read somewhere to use a tissue to get the end sharp but that didn’t get the result i was looking for. I will keep trying until all the product runs out from my trying to obtain a fine tip. I won’t be buying this again. Hopefully their other eyeliner comes in a blue for next time.

Nice, but not great

I bought two of these in different colors. They come sharp, but after a few applications, they need to be sharped and I have no way of doing that with these since they are twist up and not an actual pencil type. So then they go on a bit thicker than I like. They don't "glide" on as easily as some people reported either, but they do go on pretty well. I do like the shades I picked and they look good on me, so that is a plus.

Eyeliner that stays

I would give this five stars, but I do not like the sharpener. It' s a little too small for the width to get a good point. Otherwise, this is my favorite liner I have ever tried! Goes on smoothly and stays!